Beyond boots and bombs

by Maleeha Lodhi
02 December 2008
Print
Email
Cambridge, Massachusetts - The terrorist attacks in Mumbai have dramatised how the urgent will often take precedence over the important for the incoming Barack Obama administration.

The attacks have plunged relations between Pakistan and India into unpredictable territory just when a series of policy reviews in Washington are focussed on overhauling strategy in Afghanistan.

With Afghanistan in a “downward spiral” Washington is groping for a new strategy. It would do well to recall Lewis Carroll’s famous line in Alice in Wonderland: “When you don’t know where you are going, any road will take you there.”

The Obama administration will need to define both where it needs to go and the way out of the quagmire in Afghanistan.

Washington recognises that no country is more pivotal than Pakistan to its goals of defeating terrorism and stabilising Afghanistan. But this relationship is today held together only at the leadership level with the wider establishments and publics in both nations viewing the other with suspicion, even hostility. The trust deficit must be addressed as this will determine the quality of cooperation that Washington and Islamabad can mobilise to avert the chaos that now threatens to engulf the region.

President-elect Obama should break from the Bush legacy of treating Pakistan as hired help rather than valued ally. Pakistan has paid a heavy price for being America’s frontline ally. Thousands of people, including 2,000 military personnel, have been killed in terrorist attacks since 2001. Economic losses are estimated at $34 billion.

Three decades of strife in Afghanistan have taken a heavy toll on Pakistan. George W. Bush’s flawed Afghan strategy compounded by the fatal distraction of Iraq, widened the conflagration and pushed the war into Pakistan.

Obama has pledged a troop surge in Afghanistan. But without a fundamental change in strategy, this may increase the sense of occupation and mire the United States in a war without end. Moscow deployed more than 150,000 troops at the height of its occupation of Afghanistan and failed to avoid defeat.

A more realistic approach must start with redefining US goals, and distinguish between what is vital and attainable (disruption of terrorist networks) and what is desirable but best left for Afghans to undertake (transforming society).

So far Washington has lacked clarity about objectives and sought to eliminate terrorists, defeat the Taliban, transform society and promote democracy.

This has fused Pashtun nationalism with Muslim radicalism, and fuelled the growing insurgency.

Over-reliance on military force led to high civilian casualties and become a potent factor behind support for the Taliban.

A new strategy must seek to de-couple Al Qaeda and the Taliban, engage the Taliban in a reconciliation process and hold out the offer for an eventual withdrawal of foreign forces in return for a cessation of attacks and support for the creation of a viable Afghan army. Bombing campaigns should be replaced by political accommodation and economic development.

A new Afghan grand assembly (or Loya Jirga) should be called to endorse this process. Washington should also help orchestrate a regional consensus to back this plan that should include Iran and Russia.

Washington should cease unilateral missile strikes into Pakistan’s territory. These attacks have inflamed public opinion, undercut Pakistan’s own counter-insurgency efforts and risk shattering ties with Islamabad.

Instead the United States should strengthen Pakistan’s own capacity to fight militancy.

A new US approach should also recognise that Pakistan’s stability depends not just on containing militancy but also on strengthening the economy and on addressing its long adversarial relationship with India.

Economic help to Pakistan should be construed more in trade than in aid terms. The Obama administration should make a preferential trade deal for Pakistani textiles — the lifeblood of its economy — the centrepiece of economic assistance. Trade creates jobs and durable income that are more effective anti-terrorism tools than bombs and bullets.

Obama has already acknowledged the need to resolve the long-running Kashmir dispute to enable Pakistan to switch focus from India to counter-insurgency. Washington should launch a diplomatic initiative aimed at reaching an accommodation between Pakistan and India.

This may seem a daunting menu, but continuing with present policy promises to sink the region in a whirlpool of chaos.

###

* Dr. Maleeha Lodhi is a Fellow at Harvard’s Kennedy School and a former Pakistani ambassador to the United Kingdom and the United States. This article is distributed by the Common Ground News Service (CGNews) with permission from The Daily Times.

Source: Daily Times, 1 December 2008, www.dailytimes.com.pk
Copyright permission is granted for publication.
 
 
 
 
VIDEO OF THE WEEK
Women of Tunisia: Let your voices be heard!

The women of Tunisia have a decisive role to play in shaping Tunisia's future. Fatma Ben Saïdane reminds women of the power of their vote and the importance of civic engagement.
 
 
 
 
"The articles of the Common Ground News Service give hope that there are people out there who work on solutions inspired by the need to co-exist in tolerance and by the hope for a better future."

- Christopher Patten, Former Commissioner for External Relations, the European Commission
 
 
 

It takes 200+ hours a week to produce CGNews. We rely on readers like you to make it happen. If you find our stories informative or inspiring, help us share these underreported perspectives with audiences around the world.

Monthly:

Donate:

Or, support us with a one-time donation.

 
 
 
OTHER ARTICLES IN EDITION
Signs of hope in the Middle East
Muslims in France are French first
Women’s rights on paper versus in practice
Arabs should act, not wait for Obama
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
200+
 
 
# of hours per week to create one edition
 
 
8
 
 
# of editors in 6 countries around the world
 
 
30,000
 
 
# of subscribers
 
 
30
 
 
Average # of reprints per article
 
 
4,800
 
 
# of media outlets that have reprinted our articles
 
 
37,307
 
 
# of republished articles since inception
 
 
6
 
 
# of languages CG articles are distributed in
 
 
2000+
 
 
# of writers since inception
 
 
'

 

Other articles in this edition

Signs of hope in the Middle East by Ghassan Michel Rubeiz
Muslims in France are French first by Jean-Pierre Filiu
Women’s rights on paper versus in practice by Saba Jamal
Arabs should act, not wait for Obama by James J. Zogby